Review of Research Development Concerning Performances of Urban Green Space in China

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1000-0232.2020.03.019

Abstract

Abstract: ABSTRACT　The performance of urban green space is attracting more attention as issues concerning resource and environmental management intensify. The impact and method of evaluation for the performance of urban green spaces are critical as measurements are influenced directly by the level of urban development practical demands. In order to evaluate the development process, future research trends, and methods of assessment for urban green space performance in China, relevant research from the past 40 years were collected. This literature was divided into three stages, beginning, rapid growth and comprehensive development, using CiteSpace. A literature attribute system was established to subdivide collected works by performance type, evaluation method and level. Overall characteristics of relevant research in China were revealed through a quantitative analysis based on publication time, research hotspots, and field distribution. Characteristics of research hotspots, performance implications, and evaluation methods in each stage, as well as their development features, were also discussed. Finally, problems, highlights and research development trends on the performance of urban green space in China were summarized and relevant prospects introduced.

Key words: KEY WORDS urban green space, park land, performance, indicator, review

摘要： 摘要随着资源与环境问题加剧，城市绿地绩效受到更多关注。由于城市绿地绩效认知和衡量直接受城市发展水平及现实需求影响其内涵认知和评测方法具有较强动态性和现实性。为深入解析我国城市绿地绩效内涵及评测方法的演进过程及趋势，应用将近 40 年我国相关研究文献分为起步、快速增长、全面发展 3 个阶段展开梳理，同时以绩效类型、评测方法以及评测层面三个属性特征为切入点，建立绩效研究的文献属性框架对文献类别细分，通过计量分析从文献发表时间、研究热点和领域分布三个方面揭示各个阶段城市绿地绩效研究总体特征，并对不同时期研究热点、绩效内涵及评测方法的特征及其演进脉络展开讨论，最后对我国城市绿地绩效研究的问题、要点和发展趋势进行思考和展望

关键词: 关键词　城市绿地, 公园绿地, 绩效, 评价指标, 综述

ZHOU Cong-hui, ZHAO Qin-si, XIE Meng, JIANG Dai-yu. Review of Research Development Concerning Performances of Urban Green Space in China[J]. South Architecture, 2020, 0(3): 19-26.

周聪惠赵琴思谢猛姜戴裕 . 中国城市绿地绩效相关研究发展综述[J]. 南方建筑, 2020, 0(3): 19-26.

References

[1]Ministry of Land and Resources of the People's Republic of China.Shanghai Fully Deploys a New Round of Urban Master Planning[EB/OL].http://www.mlr.gov.cn/xwdt/jrxw/201405/t20140507_1316063.htm.
中华人民共和国国土资源部.上海全面部署新一轮城市总体规划[EB/OL]. http://www.mlr.gov.cn/xwdt/jrxw/201405/t20140507_1316063.htm.
[2]National New Urbanization Plan:2014-2020[M].Beijing:People's Publishing House,2014.
国家新型城镇化规划：2014-2020年[M].北京：人民出版社，2014.
[3]PENG Jian-feng.Human Resource Management[M].Shanghai:Fudan University Press,2003.
彭剑锋.人力资源管理概论[M].上海：复旦大学出版社，2003.
[4]YAN Wen-tao,XIAO Jing-hao,HU Hai,et al.Urban Spatial Structure and Environmental Performance:Review and Thought[J].Urban Planning Forum,2012(5):50-59.
颜文涛，萧敬豪，胡海，等.城市空间结构的环境绩效：进展与思考[J].城市规划学刊，2012（5）：50-59.
[5]ZHOU Cong-hui,JIN Yun-feng.Establishment and Planning Practice of the Multiple Classification Framework of Urban Green Space Led by the Delicacy Theory[J].Urban Development Studies,2014,21(11):118-124.
周聪惠，金云峰.“精细化”理念下的城市绿地复合型分类框架建构与规划应用[J].城市发展研究，2014，21（11）：118-124.
[6]Canfield J,Yang B,Whitlow H.Evaluating Landscape Performance--A Guidebook for Metrics and Methods Selection[R].Landscape Architecture Foundation,2018.
[7]WANG Fang-yu.Observation on the Benefit of Purifying Green Space in Chengdu[J].Journal of Sichuan Forestry Science and Technology,1982(2):85-89.
王芳瑜.成都市绿地净化效益观察[J].四川林业科技，1982（2）：85-89.
[8]All Glory is the Product of Labor[N].People's Daily,1983-03-19(1).
一切光荣都是劳动的产物[N].人民日报,1983-03-19(1).
[9]Ministry of Construction of the People's Republic of China.Classification of Urban Land Use and Planning Standards:GBJ 137—90[S].Beijing:China Architecture&Building Press,1990.
中华人民共和国建设部.城市用地分类与规划建设用地标准：GBJ 137—90[S].北京：中国建筑工业出版社,1990.
[10]State Council.Urban Greening Ordinance[Z].1992.
国务院.城市绿化条例[Z].1992.
[11]CHENG Shi,CHENG Yu-ning.From Garden City to Park City Design:The Dialectic Relationship between Urban Ecology and Morphology[J].Chinese Landscape Architecture,2018,34(12):41-45.
成实，成玉宁.从园林城市到公园城市设计——城市生态与形态辨证[J].中国园林，2018，34(12)：41-45.
[12]Ministry of Construction of the People's Republic of China.Standard for Classification of Urban Green Space CJJ/T 85—2002[S].Beijing:China Architecture & Building Press,2002.
中华人民共和国建设部.城市绿地分类标准CJJ/T 85—2002[S].北京：中国建筑工业出版社，2002.
[13]SUN Xiao-chun.Discussion on Urban Green Space Index of Garden City[J].Chinese Landscape Architecture,2009,25(9):80-84.
孙晓春.关于国家园林城市绿地指标的探讨[J].中国园林，2009，25（9）：80-84.
[14]CAI Wen-ting,Jiang Na.Interpretation of the Revision Standards and Administrative Measures of National Garden City Series[J].Chinese Landscape Architecture,2017,33(4):40-43.
蔡文婷，姜娜.《国家园林城市系列标准和申报评审管理办法》修订解读[J].中国园林，2017，033（4）：40-43.
[15]ZHOU Cong-hui.Research on Conceptual Connotation and Assessing Methods of the Performance of Parkland[J].Urban Planning International,2020,35(2):73-79.
周聪惠.公园绿地绩效的概念内涵及评测方法体系研究[J].国际城市规划，2020，35（2）：73-79.
[16]Boulton C,Dedekorkut-Howes A,Byrne J.Factors Shaping Urban Green Space Provision:A Systematic Review of the Literature[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning,2018,178:82-101.
[17]Wolch J R,Byrne J,Newell J P.Urban Green Space,Public Health, and Environmental Justice:The Challenge of Making Cities‘Just Green Enough’[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2014,125(Supplement C):234-244.
[18]Rigolon A.A Complex Landscape of Inequity in Access to Urban Parks:A Literature Review[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2016,153(Supplement C):160-169.
[19]Written by Douglass C North.Institutions，Institutional Change and Economic Performance[M].Translated by HANG Xing.Shanghai:Shanghai People's Publishing House,2014.
Douglass C North.制度、制度变迁与经济绩效[M].杭行，译.上海：上海人民出版社，2014.
[20]FU Ya-he,XU Yu-lin.Performance Appraisal and Performance Management[M].Beijing:Publishing House of Electronics Industry,2003.
付亚和，许玉林.绩效考核与绩效管理[M].北京：电子工业出版社， 2003.
[21]DIAO Xing,CHENG Wen.Urban Space Performance Evaluation[J].Planners,2015(8):110-115.
刁星，程文.城市空间绩效评价指标体系构建及实践[J].规划师，2015（8）：110-115.
[22]ZHOU Yong-xing,LV Yu-hui,LI Tian,et al.Analysis and Optimization on Operational Efficiency of Performance Evaluate Net of Industrial Land[J].Urban Development Studies,2017,24(9): 7-9,21.
周咏馨，吕玉惠，李恬，等.工业用地绩效评价网络运行效率的分析与优化[J].城市发展研究，2017，24（9）：7-9，21.
[23]ZHOU Cong-hui,WU Yun,HU Ying,et al.Green Spectrum along the City Wall-Graphic Analysis of Spatial Characteristics and Service Performance of the Nanjing Ming Dynasty City Wall Greenway[M].Nanjing:Southeast University Press,2017.
周聪惠，吴韵，胡樱，等.城垣下的绿谱—南京明城墙绿道空间特征与服务绩效图解[M].南京：东南大学出版社，2017.
[24]ZHOU Cong-hui.Research on Conceptual Connotation and Assessing Methods of the Performance of Parkland[J].Urban Planning International,2020,35(2):1-12.
周聪惠.公园绿地绩效的概念内涵及评测方法体系研究[J].国际城市规划，2020，35（2）：1-12.
[25]PENG Kun-tao,ZHAO Min.Urban Spatial Performance and Urban Planning Efficiency[J].City Planning Review,2010(8):9-17.
彭坤焘，赵民.关于“城市空间绩效”及城市规划的作为[J].城市规划，2010（8）：9-17.
[26]WANG Xu-dong,CHEN Yao,CHEN Shan,et al.Construction of Town Green Land Ecological Networks Based on Spatial Performance Taking Liqiao Town,Xuancheng in Anhui as an Example[J].Journal of Central South University of Forestry & Technology,2016(3): 87-95.
王旭东，陈尧，陈闪，等.基于空间绩效的城镇绿地生态网络构建——以安徽宣城狸桥为例[J].中南林业科技大学学报，2016（3）：87-95.
[27]JIANG Hai-yan,ZHOU Chun-shan,GAO Jun-bo.Advance in the Equity of Spatial Distribution of Urban Public Service in Western Countries[J].City Planning Review,2011,35(7):72-77.
江海燕，周春山，高军波.西方城市公共服务空间分布的公平性研究进展[J].城市规划，2011，35（7）：72-77.
[28]YE Lin,XING Zhong,YAN Wen-tao,et al.Urban Greenspace Planning to Achieve Social Justice[J].Urban Planning Forum,2018(3):57-64.
叶林，邢忠，颜文涛，等.趋近正义的城市绿色空间规划途径探讨[J].城市规划学刊，2018（3）：57-64.